Go beyond personalized gifts this Valentine’s Day with personalized cookies and treats that will melt their hearts!

cookie box

The only thing better than giving your loved ones a personalized gift this Valentine’s Day is giving them a personalized gift with a personalized treat inside!

We instantly fell in love with the personalized cookie idea after we caught a glimpse of this adorable photo. We just can’t believe we never thought of it ourselves! The idea is to decorate one large cookie with “I love you more than …” and lay it down on top of a dozen or so cookies that are each personalized with an example.

There are endless possibilities that you can work with when you’re decorating the cookies for your significant other. And we know the perfect way to present the yummy personalized treats on Valentine’s Day in one of our adorable personalized cookie jars!

We also love the idea of sending them to your boyfriend, fiancé or husband at work on Valentine’s Day. Women are always getting flowers, teddy bears and other gifts delivered to them at work or at home on Valentine’s Day, and we think it’s about time that there was a non-feminine, romantic gift that was acceptable to send to your man. Men have been publicly expressing their love on this romantic holiday forever and now we have the perfect gift to help you return the favor. While having flowers or teddy bears delivered to his office may embarrass him, receiving delicious cookies in a personalized cookie jar is sure to be the highlight of his day! He’ll not only love the homemade treats, he’ll be proud to show off his wife or girlfriend’s baking skills to all of his coworkers, too!

Stained Glass Heart Cookies


If you’re worried about your cookie-decorating skills or if your Valentine prefers chocolate to sugar cookies we also have some other treat ideas to share with you. Thanks to the How To Nest For Less Blog, we found a great recipe for Stained Glass Heart Cookies.

These cookies look beautiful and all you have to do is take a heart-shaped cookie cutter to a sugar cookie and fill in the space with pieces of crushed Jolly Rancher candy. After baking you’ll have a delicious and colorful cookie to give to your Valentine!

Pinterest Tip: As we were browsing through all of the great Valentine’s Day dessert ideas on Pinterest we saw how some people had used two different colors of Jolly Ranchers to give their cookies a swirl or tie-dye look!

White Chocolare M&Ms Valentaine’s Day Cookie Bars

valentine's cookie bars

If your loved one is a chocaholic you should check out The Gunny Sack Blog’s recipe for White Chocolate M&M’s Valentine’s Day Cookie Bars. The recipe is super easy because the crust is actually made from a cake mix. The recipe also calls for white chocolate chips and Valentine’s Day M&M’s. We love how the M&Ms turn the bars pink and red!

Do you have a special Valentine’s Day treat that you’re planning on making for your sweetheart this year? We’d love to hear it! Post your recipe or thoughts in a comment below!


Kate Sabino is the Senior Paid Social Manager at Personalization Mall.

Write A Comment